Best Burgers and Milkshakes Near East Harlem, NYC

Looking for the best burgers and milkshakes near East Harlem? At Harlem Shake®, we serve griddle-smashed beef burgers, organic milkshakes, and fries at 100 W. 124th Street at Lenox Avenue. 

Our original restaurant is in Central Harlem, west of East Harlem, not within it. Come for a straightforward cheeseburger and vanilla shake, or take your order in a bolder direction with jerk fries on your burger and red velvet cake in your shake.

East Harlem is also known as Spanish Harlem or El Barrio. If that’s where you’re coming from, here’s what to know about our corner of Harlem, what’s on the menu, and how to put together a meal worth heading over for.

Why Make Harlem Shake® Your Burger-and-Shake Stop?

Our burgers start with a custom Pat LaFrieda blend of chuck, rib, and brisket. We smash the beef on the griddle and cook it until crisp, serving our beef burgers juicy and well done. That preparation gives the burger its contrast: browned edges, melted cheese, and a soft roll around it all.

The details don’t stop at the beef. Our Martin’s Potato Rolls are toasted with Upstate New York butter. Homemade pickles bring tang to the Harlem Classic, while jerk mayo, pickled cherry pepper, and bacon relish take other burgers in distinctly different directions. You can keep your order simple without settling for a plain meal.

Shakes get the same attention. We make them with organic NY Fresh by Organic Valley whole milk and organic Blue Marble ice cream, then build flavors with ingredients such as homemade salted caramel and red velvet cake from Harlem’s Make My Cake.

We opened at West 124th Street and Lenox Avenue in May 2013. As our Harlem Shake® story explains, the restaurant draws inspiration from neighborhood eateries including Pan Pan and M&G Diner. Our name honors the original Harlem Shake® dance created by Al B. at Rucker Park. The old-school setting and burger-and-shake menu belong to that neighborhood-minded approach: familiar food, a welcoming place, and a reason to sit down together.

Which Smash Burger Should You Order?

The main decision is what you want around the beef: classic cheeseburger toppings, jerk seasoning, or the layered heat and richness of the Hot Mess. Each has a clear identity, so start with the ingredients you actually crave.

Harlem Classic: Start With the Essentials

The Harlem Classic combines our Pat LaFrieda beef blend with American cheese, homemade pickles, onions, and special sauce on a buttered, toasted Martin’s Potato Roll.

This is our recommendation when you want the beef and griddle cooking to lead. Pickles and onions cut through the richness, while American cheese and special sauce bring everything together. It’s also a useful starting point for a first order: you get the foundations of our burger menu without adding several competing toppings.

Choose it when your ideal burger is a cheeseburger done with care, not an exercise in how much can fit inside a bun.

Harlem Jerk: Put the Fries on the Burger

The Harlem Jerk comes with two Pat LaFrieda beef patties, American cheese, pickles, and onions, topped with jerk fries and jerk mayo.

The fries are part of the burger itself, adding potato and seasoning to the beef-and-cheese combination. Jerk mayo carries that flavor through the rest of the toppings. Compared with the Classic, this is a more layered order, particularly if you like seasoned fries and don’t want to save them all for the side.

If you’re choosing between the Jerk and the Hot Mess, let the toppings decide: go Jerk for seasoned fries and jerk mayo; go Hot Mess for cherry pepper, bacon relish, and chipotle.

Hot Mess: Choose Pepper, Bacon, and Chipotle

Our Hot Mess stacks two Pat LaFrieda beef patties with American cheese, pickles, onions, pickled cherry pepper, bacon relish, and smoky chipotle mayo on a toasted Martin’s Potato Roll.

The combination brings peppery tang, bacon richness, and smoky sauce to the same burger. It’s the choice we’d suggest when you want your toppings to have as much personality as the beef.

You can compare these burgers and the other patty options on our current food and shake menu. Read each description carefully if ingredients matter to your order: a different patty does not necessarily mean different sauces or toppings. Our homemade veggie patties also contain nuts.

Milkshakes Near East Harlem: Find Your Flavor

Our shake menu ranges from vanilla and chocolate to fruit flavors, nut flavors, and our signature red velvet shake. Start by deciding what sounds good alongside your burger: a familiar classic, a fruit-forward flavor, or something closer to dessert in a cup.

For a traditional pairing, the Vanilla Shake includes French vanilla, while the Chocolate Shake uses homemade chocolate paste made with pure Dutch cocoa. The Black & White combines half chocolate and half vanilla. Our Old-School Vanilla Malt adds malt powder to a vanilla shake.

Strawberry and Mango take a different direction, combining vanilla with Italian wild strawberry or mango paste. Salted Caramel uses our homemade caramel, and Cookies & Cream brings crushed Oreos into the mix.

Then there’s The Harlem Shake®, our signature shake made with Blue Marble ice cream and red velvet cake from Make My Cake. If you want one order that connects directly to the restaurant’s Harlem identity, this is a good place to start.

Pistachio, Hazelnut, and Peanut Butter shakes are also listed on the menu and contain nuts. The Mocha Shake includes Italian coffee concentrate and contains caffeine. Check ingredients with our team before ordering if you have a food allergy or another dietary concern.

Three Burger-and-Shake Pairings We Recommend

These are our pairing suggestions, not a ranking of what everyone else orders.

  • Harlem Classic + The Harlem Shake®: Keep the burger focused on beef, cheese, pickles, and special sauce, then let the red velvet shake take the dessert role. This would be our starting recommendation for someone trying both sides of the menu.

  • Harlem Jerk + Vanilla Shake: Pair the burger’s jerk fries and jerk mayo with a straightforward vanilla shake. It’s a deliberate contrast rather than another layer of seasoning.

  • Hot Mess + Chocolate Shake: Choose this when you want a full-flavored meal from start to finish. The burger brings cherry pepper, bacon relish, and chipotle mayo; the shake brings Dutch cocoa.

Add Fries That Fit Your Order

Regular fries are a good match when your burger already has plenty going on. For a different side, our yam waffle fries are dusted with smoked paprika and served with maple-cider vinegar mayo.

Want to lean into the seasoning? Jerk fries come dusted with our proprietary jerk seasoning blend and served with jerk mayo. Or try Dardra’s Parmesan Truffle Fries, finished with shaved Parmigiano Reggiano, garlic, parsley, and white truffle oil.

One practical ingredient note: our standard fry preparation uses canola oil and beef tallow. Ask our team about your specific needs rather than assuming a potato side fits a particular diet.

Plan Your Visit From East Harlem

Harlem Shake® is at West 124th Street and Lenox Avenue, west of East Harlem’s Fifth Avenue boundary. That makes us a nearby Central Harlem destination for people searching for burgers near Spanish Harlem, rather than a restaurant located inside El Barrio.

Your route will depend on where you’re starting. Use the restaurant’s exact address when checking directions, especially if you’re planning around another stop.

  • Address: 100 W. 124th Street at Lenox Avenue, New York, NY 10027.

  • Hours: Sunday through Thursday, 11 a.m. to 11 p.m.; Friday and Saturday, 11 a.m. to 2 a.m.

  • Phone: (212) 222-8300.

  • Location details: Check our Harlem restaurant page before heading over.

  • Online pickup: Use ordering for 124th Street and Lenox Avenue to select an available pickup day and time.

We also offer ordering through the Harlem Shake® app. Pickup and delivery options depend on location and availability; check the ordering system for your address rather than assuming delivery reaches every part of East Harlem.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where Can I Get Burgers and Milkshakes Near East Harlem?

Harlem Shake® serves smash burgers, fries, and organic milkshakes at 100 W. 124th Street at Lenox Avenue. Our original restaurant is in Central Harlem, west of East Harlem.

Is Harlem Shake® Located in East Harlem?

No. Our Manhattan restaurant is in Central Harlem at West 124th Street and Lenox Avenue. East Harlem, also known as Spanish Harlem or El Barrio, lies to the east, with Fifth Avenue generally marking its western boundary.

What Burgers Can I Order at Harlem Shake®?

Our menu includes the Harlem Classic, Harlem Jerk, and Hot Mess. The Classic features American cheese, homemade pickles, onions, and special sauce. The Jerk adds jerk fries and jerk mayo, while the Hot Mess includes pickled cherry pepper, bacon relish, and smoky chipotle mayo.

What Milkshake Flavors Does Harlem Shake® Offer?

Our menu includes vanilla, chocolate, Black & White, strawberry, mango, salted caramel, Cookies & Cream, pistachio, mocha, hazelnut, peanut butter, and Old-School Vanilla Malt. Our signature Harlem Shake® combines Blue Marble ice cream with Make My Cake red velvet cake. Check the current menu for availability and ingredient details.

Can I Order Harlem Shake® Online?

Yes. Our Harlem ordering page lets you choose an available pickup day and time, and you can also order through the Harlem Shake® app. Delivery is offered at participating locations, subject to availability for your address.

Come Over for Harlem Burgers and Shakes

Start with the Classic or go straight for the Hot Mess. Keep your shake old-school, or make it red velvet. However you build your order, we’ll be at 124th and Lenox. Take a look at the menu, check your route, or place a pickup order, and make your next burger-and-shake outing a Harlem Shake® one.